*Army of Me*
Washington DC-based Army of Me have been around for quite a while and, after a litany of EPs, theyâ€™ve finally managed to get a full-length album together. I saw them perform in their hometown, where they played a thoroughly charming opening set for Mae, and kicked the butts of their then far more popular co-openers The Spill Canvas. Their debut is, like many debuts, a retread of several of their previous releases (thus we know out of the gate that it isnâ€™t going to be a cohesive concept album or, in all likelihood, make any serious, ten-track point). But considering Army of Meâ€™s strengths, 1) thatâ€™s not a bad thing, and 2) itâ€™s not necessarily what they would be looking to do, anyway.
Songwriting frontman Vince Scheuerman doesnâ€™t come off as an indie _artiste_, but there is something peculiarly magnetic about his songs (that mirrors, I might add, his earnest, unassuming stage persona). The opening of opener â€œPerfectâ€ is about as tepid as they come, with forgettable lyrics to match, but when Scheuerman sings â€œone day, Iâ€™ll be perfect, Iâ€™ll be / So extraordinary, I will take your breath away!â€ we instantly believe him. And when a sensitive, pretty (and Iâ€™m resisting the temptation to say Coldplay-ish) guitar riff joins his smooth vocals, itâ€™s all over.
â€œRiseâ€ immediately struck me when I first heard it live, and the recorded version encapsulates everything I love about this band. It also, Iâ€™ll admit, plays to every musical weak spot Iâ€™ve got, namely acoustic guitar licks, tight harmonies, and I-IV-V chord progressions. For the first minute, itâ€™s nothing that youâ€™d blink if you heard it on a Top 40 station played by say, Simple Plan. The intricate folksy guitar work that seems appropriate is missing, but Schuermanâ€™s strong sense of melody and confident singing (especially when his bandmates join him in stacked harmony singing, â€œRise, rise, rise!â€) is just delightful. Small, but exactly what itâ€™s intended to be.
â€œRiseâ€ is also a good point to talk about Army of Meâ€™s place, if they have one, in the world of music made by Christians. Iâ€™ve never seen the band ever refer to themselves as a â€œChristian bandâ€ or be really associated with anyone who does, but lyrical themes and subtle scriptural imagery (or not so subtle, as in â€œMeet You at the Mouthâ€) make it indisputable. On â€œRise,â€ for example, Scheuerman sings â€œI was lying in the gutter, crawling in the streets / now the servants are all sitting in the most distinguished seats.â€ He expresses, in one line, what it takes Aaron Shust entire albums of clichÃ©s to get across, and even does it with a deft reference to scripture that is intellectually acceptable and artistically appropriate.
Lest I get too into enjoying the sound of my own voice gushing, I will remind that Army of Me is indeed a young, radio-friendly alternative rock band and little more. _Citizen_ is nothing that hasnâ€™t been done to a fault on rock radio, but it clings to a sensitivity that makes Army of Meâ€™s take on the pop-rock track considerably more memorable. And on a surface level, they manage not to sound too much like anyone else in their league. Magnetic melody pervades not only Scheuermanâ€™s vocal lines, but also every note played by lead guitarist Brad Tursi, who can make his strings weepily react to Scheuermanâ€™s singing with an at times heart-wrenching subtlety (see â€œBetter Runâ€). He does energetic just as wellâ€”â€œHow Longâ€ wanders closer to Yellowcard-like radio territory, but Tursiâ€™s work makes an unsurprising song one that Iâ€™d actually listen to again.
â€œMeet You at the Mouthâ€ is interesting for its clash of identities, this time between Scheuermanâ€™s conventional, pop-appropriate singing and the rest of the bandâ€™s chance to mix up the repertoire. I wonâ€™t get Radiohead-comparison-happy, but Tursiâ€™s soloing sounds much more like something off The Bends than it does Mae (which _Citizen_ faintly mirrors). Itâ€™s an intriguing glimpse into the bandâ€™s very apparent artistic intelligence and perhaps a nod to some good influences, but putting Vinceâ€™s voice through a filter doesnâ€™t quite meet the need for a less-conventional vocalist to complete the left-of-center romp.
And falling too squarely in the center is where _Citizen_ â€™s fault lies; it consistently clings to formula even as it recognizes the need to branch out. These songs do the formula well, but as a collection theyâ€™re ultimately grounded by it. As a set, mid-tempo drags and becomes sluggish, monotonous; tracks fade together and become forgettable. Iâ€™ve never heard a band pull off that sort of dazed disinterest as well as the Fray, and, late in the record, Army of Me floats down slowly, dangerously toward Frayishness. Theyâ€™re more interesting, though, and this album should stay in the player a lot longer than How to Save a Life ever hoped to. Citizen is a satisfying if not exciting debut, and bears the marks of a band that might have it in them to become great. I guess in the sea of young men playing alternative rock, a little genuine earnestness goes a long way.
David Sessions is the editor of The CCM Patrol.
Tags2012 Election Andrew Sullivan Arts Atheism Barack Obama Bible Books Capitalism Catholic Church Charles Taylor Christian Christianity Christianity Today Church Conservatism Conservatives Evangelicalism Evangelicals Facebook Feminism Gay Marriage God Gospel Coalition History Jacques Derrida Jesus Journalism Mark Driscoll Marriage Martin Heidegger Marvin Olasky Marxism Media New Sincerity New York Times Patheos Philosophy Politics Religion Religion and Spirituality Ross Douthat Same-sex marriage United States Women Young Evangelicals