Patrol Magazine

THE ARTS | THE TIMES | THE CITY | OPINION | BLOGS | PODCASTS

Fix the Lists 2008: Pitchfork

Today, we present our final Fix The List: the long-awaited annual Pitchfork Top 50.

By The Editors    Dec 19, 2008    SHARE

Updated December 10, 2008 at 11:47 PM

IT’S THAT time of year again—time when the music blogs start buzzing with end-of-year best album list talk, outraged comments start piling up, and you start wondering what good lists are in the first place. They’re always so wrong, right?

This year, we had an idea to fix the frustration of endlessly debating on blogs about how the album lists should have turned out—after they’re already set in stone. Thanks to our friends at Slinkset, we’ve set up an interface that hands you each list—Pitchfork, Stereogum, Paste, you name it—and lets you give it another round of editing.

There is little need to explain how it works, because there is so little to it. We post the original lists, with the site/magazine’s original placement, and you rearrange them. Here, however, is a sample graphic and a couple of tips:

1. Vote by clicking the up or down arrows to signal which direction it should be moving on the list (higher or lower).

2. Yell at other fellow voters via threaded comments on each album (click the “comment” link underneath the summary). You only get one vote, but you can always change it (click the arrow again to clear it).

3. Crusade. Argue in the comments and get voters to change their minds! Send this page to your friends to get your favorites more votes. Make war, not love.

That’s it! We will add new lists as they’re released, and compile them all here:

Paste magazine (Top 50 albums of the year)
Added December 1, 2008

Stereogum (Top 50 albums of the year)
Added December 10, 2008

BONUS: Patrol’s People of 2008
Added December 11, 2008

Pitchfork (Top 50 albums of the year)
Added December 19, 2008

If you have any questions about or suggestions for Fix the Lists, please send us an email at feedback@patrolmag.com.


Christopher Cocca is a graduate of Yale Divinity School and is currently working toward an MFA in fiction at The New School in New York City.


Latest on Patrol


Defining the Indefinite

What indie music and faith have in common.



Chasing Amy

When the publisher of CCM forced me to force Amy Grant to apologize for her divorce.



The Gospel According to Makoto Fujimura

The Japanese-American painter talks about Christianity, Eastern spiritualism, and the nature of art.






From the Archives


Chasing Amy

When the publisher of CCM forced me to force Amy Grant to apologize for her divorce.



Spiritual Born Killers

How the military hopes religion will make American soldiers better fighters.



Streaming for Gold

Netflix’s online streaming feature is perfect for its sizable collection of offbeat independent documentaries.